The Iona Blog

Opinions contained in The Iona Blog are not necessarily those of The Iona Institute. The Iona Blog is open to anyone who broadly shares the views of The Iona Institute. If you wish to post a comment on a relevant topic please email 200 – 400 words to [email protected] and it will be considered for inclusion in the blog.

 

Michael McDowell believes the ideal is to be raised by a mother and father. So why not promote it?

By David Quinn on 26 Jan 15. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Former Justice Minister, Attorney General and PD member, Michael McDowell may dissent from liberal orthodoxies on matters of economics but he has always been reliably liberal on social issues and therefore it is no surprise that he is for same-sex marriage. But I’m not sure about his reasoning.

 

Does the Yes side believe in the ‘Irish mammy’ or not?

By Ben Conroy on April 10 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Tánaiste Joan Burton (pictured) has been telling a story recently. She recounted it at the end of her speech at the Labour Party Conference, and told the Irish language online magazine Tuairisc.ie too. Speaking in support of a Yes vote in the marriage referendum, Burton says that she was struck by one woman she met in Moneygall, Co Offaly, who said she wanted her son, who is gay, to "settle down". "This was an Irish mammy thing," she said. "

 

The modern version of ‘error has no rights’

By David Quinn on 7 April 15. ~ Categories: Freedom of Conscience and Religion

We know a moral viewpoint has hardened and slipped its moorings when it will brook no public dissent. The pro-same sex marriage viewpoint has reached that stage. Those who do not believe in same-sex marriage are to be treated by society as the moral equivalent of racists and under certain circumstances to be prosecuted by the law. We see this happening right now in Indiana

 

Indiana Hysteria Is A Warning for Ireland

By Ben Conroy on 2nd April 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family,Freedom of Conscience and Religion

As the debate over same-sex marriage continues in the lead-up to Ireland's referendum on the question, the prospect of allowing a "conscience clause" has been thoroughly rejected by the Yes side. The US State of Indiana recently tried to pass a law that might give some prospect of protection to the likes of Asher's - and it's fair to say that supporters of same-sex marriage exploded.

 

David Quinn and Colm O'Gorman Debate Same-Sex Marriage "Conscience Clause"

By Admin on 27th March 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

David Quinn appeared on Morning Ireland, debating Colm O'Gorman of Amnesty International about the introduction of a "conscience clause" protecting the freedom of conscience rights of bakers, printers, and other citizens who don't support same-sex marriage, in the event that the referendum was passed. It's an important and relevent debate to have, as the Asher's Bakery case in Northern Ireland is currently ongoing. In that case, a small family-run bakery was asked to bake a cake bearing the slogan "Support Gay Marriage" and then taken to court by Northern Ireland's equality commission when they refused.

 

Union of a man and a woman "irreplaceable" says Archbishop Martin

By Admin on 20 March 15. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Last night Archbishop Diarmuid Martin addressed a meeting of The Iona Institute attended by over 200 people. His topic was 'The Teaching of the Church on Marriage Today'. In the course of the talk he addressed the topic of the nature of marriage.

 

Questions the media aren't asking, and the Yes side aren't answering

By Ben Conroy on 19th March 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

The two sides in this referendum debate, so far as I can see, don't just disagree. They disagree about what it is they're disagreeing about. Most of those I've seen arguing for a Yes vote sincerely believe that this is, wholly and solely, a debate about who should be able to get married.Unfortunately for the public, the media are (for the most part) accepting the Yes side’s framing of the issue. In a fairer debate, it'd be great to hear the Yes side, and those who fully support the Children and Family Relationships Bill (CFR Bill), being asked questions like this:

 

The testimony of a donor-conceived adult

By Ben Conroy on 12th March 2014. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family,Other

Elizabeth Howard, a woman from England who was conceived through sperm donation, was on the Right Hook programme on Newstalk yesterday. Howard, who wrote for the Guardian last year about the experience of being the child of an anonymous “donor”, made it clear to George Hook that she thought all sperm donation was unethical. “I don't think removing anonymity really helps” she said.

 

What Pope Francis said when same-sex marriage was being debated in Argentina

By David Quinn on 11 March 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

In 2010, Argentina legalised same-sex marriage. At the time, Pope Francis was Archbishop of Buenos Aires. He voiced his strong opposition to the proposal. This is quite contrary to the common misconception that he is silent on the issue. Since becoming Pope, Francis has reiterated many of the things he said in Argentina.

 

Fergus Finlay, Falling Skies, and Three Simple Questions on the Family Bill

By Ben Conroy on 5th March 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Fergus Finlay was writing in The Irish Examiner this week about the Child and Family relationships, and his piece unfortunately follows a familiar template adopted by most of the legislation's defenders. It goes something like this: 1. Talk about the good bits of the bill 2. Avoid any questions that might be awkward. 3. Assure people that everything's A-OK, and that anyone who raises any of the questions you've just dodged is peddling fear.

 

How different polling questions on same-sex marriage get different results

By David Quinn on 2 March 15. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

When two different questions get quite different results on the same issue it is a good sign that voter intentions on that issue are volatile. Thus it was that a poll by Red C and another one by Millward Brown on the issue of same-sex marriage and conducted within a week of each other got significantly different outcomes.

 

The Government’s disastrous attitude towards marriage

By David Quinn on 27 Feb 15. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Let’s forget for a moment about the upcoming referendum on same-sex marriage and consider instead the disastrous attitude of our Government and opposition parties towards marriage overall. Taoiseach Enda Kenny summed it up very well last week when he reduced what marriage is all about to two words, “I do”.

 

Justice Minister happy to see fathers cut out of the lives of children

By Admin on 25th February 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Frances Fitzgerald’s speech last night introducing the Children and Family Relationships Bill to the Dail was a masterpiece of evasion, in particular when she commented on the aspects of the Bill dealing with Donor Assisted Human Reproduction (DAHR). Here's what she had to say: “The Bill will not change the rights of most children in terms of parentage. A child who is the natural child of a heterosexual couple will have exactly the same parentage rights as at present. That child will continue to be the child of his or her birth mother and natural father. However, two categories of children will get the chance to GAIN a parent or parents as a result of this Bill. A donor-conceived child will get the right, under this legislation, to gain a second parent. As it stands, if the child is born to a female same-sex couple, that child has only one legally recognised parent if the donor is unknown.”

 

Explaining to Fintan O'Toole the reasoning behind Article 41

By David Quinn on Feb 19 15. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

It’s fair to say that Fintan O’Toole doesn’t like the section on the Irish Constitution that deals with the family, that is to say, Article 41. In his column in Tuesday's Irish Times he associates it with de Valera’s Ireland and finds the article to be more or less incomprehensible.

 

Stephen Fry condemns suffering, but who is doing most to alleviate it?

By Frederik Bosch on 13th February 2015. ~ Categories: Religion and Religious Practice

Stephen Fry’s latest attempt to remind the world just how relevant and intelligent he is has brought Irish media legend Gay Byrne into the debate. In his show “The Meaning of Life,” Gay asked Fry what he would say, should he encounter God at the Gates of Heaven (assuming Saint Peter has given him a pass)? His response: “I’ll say, ‘Bone cancer in children? What's that about? How dare you? How dare you create a world in which there is such misery that’s not our fault. It’s not right. It’s utterly, utterly evil. Why should I respect a capricious, mean-minded, stupid God who creates a world which is so full of injustice and pain?”

 

What the French baby mix-up reveals about the natural ties

By Ben Conroy on 10th February 2014. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

Two French families who had their daughters mixed up in hospital have been awarded over two million euro worth of damages in court. When a child is separated from their natural family by accident, it's a tragedy. But what if the child is separated from one or both of their biological parents on purpose? Isn't that a violation of rights too? That's the question supporters of sperm and egg donation and surrogacy have to answer.

 

Children lose out in The Irish Times’ wholly adult-centred view of marriage

By David Quinn on 9 Feb 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

We should be grateful to The Irish Times for setting out in its editorial today such a comprehensively adult-centred view of marriage. The newspaper is entirely happy to completely separate the issue of children from the issue of marriage and never thinks to ask whether this is actually a good thing or not. It's not, of course.

 

Could there be a legal challenge to calling it the ‘marriage equality’ referendum?

By David Quinn on 5th February 2015. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

The Government has decided to call the Bill to amend the Constitution and permit same-sex marriage," The Thirty-Fourth Amendment of the Constitution (Marriage Equality) Bill 2015". Giving it such a completely loaded name, entirely favourable to the Yes side has been called into question by legal academic, Dr Seán Ó Conaill. Dr Ó Conaill believes calling it this is constitutionally doubtful as it immediately biases voters in favour of it.

 

Is the right to a mother and father meaningless?

By Ben Conroy on 2nd February 2014. ~ Categories: Marriage and the Family

There's a persistent idea on the Yes side that notions that the idea of a child having a “right to a mother and father” or “a right to a relationship with their genetic parents” is a nonsense argument because – or so the reasoning goes – the state can't guarantee it. Their mother might tragically die, their father might walk out, and there's not much anyone can do about it. This case is made with particular regularity and force by journalist Vincent Browne. But what would happen if we applied this logic to a few other rights? How about the most basic one – the right to life?

 

The real reason why there are fewer female profs

By Frederik Bosch on 29th January 2014. ~ Categories: Other

The usual hand-wringing continues. Peter McGuire at the Irish Times is all in a tizzy about gender imbalances at professor-level in our universities. Apparently it’s all discrimination of one kind or another and has nothing to do with the choice many women make in the real world about how to properly balance home and work.

 

Showing 1 - 20 of 731 Articles | Page 1 of 37